View Single Post
Old 01-10-2007, 04:56 AM   # 2 Quick Link (permalink)
 Elmer's Avatar
Elmer
Forum Contributor
Meritorious Service Medal

Elmer is offline Offline
Photos:
Referrals:
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location:
Rocky Mountain West!
 

Re: Galland, Werner, Von Werra -- oh my!

I just got three of the 109s, couldn't help myself with that sale... Galland, Von Werra, and the Werner...

I do like them, but I don't think they're worth much more than what I paid for 'em, really. I do feel the mold detail could be better, the retracted gear option is just plain silly -- I don't mind so much the absence of a stand as I prefer "parked" display, nor do I care about the rubber bits (probably best for the long run). I think carousel should bring something to the 1:48 table to really separate itself, particularly at the 70 price point (such as moving control surfaces or I suppose the inclusion of a cool stand -- the display base does nothing for me, I'm afraid).

And what's with the staggered nose guns -- should they be this way? I think Black6 posted the same q, but I didn't see an answer??

Harry? (Oh, and Harry, should the wing roots be painted the same color as the wings -- I remember this debate with the Dragon 109s on MH I, but not the result ).

Carousel does do a nice paint job. However to me the models come off as showroom fresh whereas FM's come off as a bit used... (though I'm betting Carousel's molds are more accurate...)

Hate the stick swazi, like they at least included an option, and I think the plug for the screw hole (used for packaging) is an awesome touch!

More later.... but my initial $.02 is that the P-40s are a bit nicer. That said, I'm happy to have these three aces joining my hangar.

(Oh, I love that I got a Von Werra in 1:48 for less than it would cost me for the Corgi version, which I was sort of keeping an eye out for... )

My sentiments exactly Pappy. The 109 mold is inferior to the P-40 and the Dora: at 1:48 Carousel should/could have given it more detail. Regarding the staggered guns, I built a Tamiya 109E and the guns are staggered on that kit, very similar to Carousel's attempt; I am assuming this is correct, Tamiya is a stickler for accuracy. Don't let the 109 discourage you about the Dora though, it is fabulous! The detail is much better and the panel lines are crisp and realistic looking.
 

Check the Ebay Listings forum for the latest diecast model listings on eBay.

Click here to make a donation to support The Model Hangar.

Reply With Quote