View Single Post
Old 04-24-2008, 12:20 PM   # 48 Quick Link (permalink)
 Cruver Collecter's Avatar
Cruver Collecter
Member

Cruver Collecter is offline Offline
Photos:
Referrals:
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location:
Longview, Texas
 

Re: How critical should our model criticisms be?

I have expressed my opinion in the past on this forum. Then recently, I received a couple of "scathing" PMs regarding an opinion I've posted. As a result, I no longer feel it is safe to either give an opinion about or critique any model (or manufacturer) on this forum. That is why I seldom log in or post any more.

My personal rules are simple: (1) only post positive opinions and use the most positive language possible so as not to offend anyone. I will only post if I feel it is absolutely necessary (or I'm praising something) (2) If I do a review, I will only comment on a model I own personally and have held in my hands. I have a set format I will use (see my FoV Me262 review for example) that stresses both the positives and negatives as I see them. From now on I will not post a negative comment on any model I do not own, even if there is clear evidence that it is grossly inaccurate. (3) My P.M. preferences is shut off. If I need to contact someone, I'll turn it on as long as needed. If you need to contact me, let me know in a post. Bye.

Personally I like it when folks like you post your opinion on models you have either owned or viewed. In the past I have also caught some flak from folks that had what I can only describe as having some emotional attachement to a certain model. Since it is common ageement that there is no such thing as a perfect model, why not point out the discrepancies as well as any praise. One would think that part of this forum would be expressing ones opinion on diecast models.

I just went through your reviews, and couldn't find a thing for anyone to get whiney about. Shame to see you quit, because you put out some interesting to read reviews.
 

Brewster Buffalo, Hawk 75A, Fokker D.XXI, Polikarpov I-16, Fiat G.50, Macchi C. 200, PZL P.11c, Fieseler Fi 156 Storch ,,,, now those are real planes.