View Single Post
Old 04-24-2008, 01:59 AM   # 43 Quick Link (permalink)
Epapazian
Forum Contributor
Meritorious Service Medal

Epapazian is offline Offline
Photos:
Referrals:
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location:
New York, New York
 

Re: How critical should our model criticisms be?

I have expressed my opinion in the past on this forum. Then recently, I received a couple of "scathing" PMs regarding an opinion I've posted. As a result, I no longer feel it is safe to either give an opinion about or critique any model (or manufacturer) on this forum. That is why I seldom log in or post any more.

My personal rules are simple: (1) only post positive opinions and use the most positive language possible so as not to offend anyone. I will only post if I feel it is absolutely necessary (or I'm praising something) (2) If I do a review, I will only comment on a model I own personally and have held in my hands. I have a set format I will use (see my FoV Me262 review for example) that stresses both the positives and negatives as I see them. From now on I will not post a negative comment on any model I do not own, even if there is clear evidence that it is grossly inaccurate. (3) My P.M. preferences is shut off. If I need to contact someone, I'll turn it on as long as needed. If you need to contact me, let me know in a post. Bye.

I am sorry to read this. I hope that you will eventually reconsider but I appreciate how hurtful this sort of thing can be. I don't subscribe to the idea that one can't critique a model unless you own it.----not when there are plenty of pictures to review as well as the comments and research of others.
 

Check the Ebay Listings forum for the latest diecast model listings on eBay.

Click here to make a donation to support The Model Hangar.