Like most will tell you, CW's F-14's are the most accurate, most detailed diecast model in any scale, anywhere. I don't know the purpose of this comparison, but it'd be safe to bet that if a CW Tomcat was blown up into 1/32, it'd probably blow away the F-4J in terms of detail. Not to mention you're comparing a plastic model to a diecast one. The feel of a CW is like no other.
CW doesn't weather their planes but they do have "inked" panel lines, which gives them sort of weathered feel. Many don't care for it, I personally like it a lot.